Skip to content
Home » Best Magic Shows In New York City

Best Magic Shows In New York City

Finding an amazing experience shouldn’t be a hassle in one of the most magical cities in the world. But it can be hard to narrow down all the options and find what’s worth seeing for yourself (and seeing is believing). Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered on that front. We’ve assembled a list of the best and most fantastical magic shows in NYC, from Broadway stages to bewitching and intimate spaces.

Justin Willman at Wellmont Theatre:

Justin Willman brings a unique blend of comedy and magic to his show. Known for his Netflix series “Magic for Humans,” Willman’s performance is both relatable and mind-bending. His approachable style combines with spectacular magic tricks, making the show a family-friendly yet sophisticated experience. This event offers a chance to see a TV star magician live, adding a touch of Hollywood glamour to the New York magic scene​!

Justin Willman is a magician renowned for blending humor with jaw-dropping illusions. His show often features interactive segments with the audience, engaging them in mind-reading and telekinesis tricks. Known for levitating objects and performing thought-provoking illusions, his style is a mix of modern magic and whimsy. Expect to be part of the show as Willman is known for his audience-centric performances.

Wellmont Theatre, 5 Seymour Street, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA

Masters Of Illusion at Bergen Performing Arts Center:

This show, featuring the stars of the CW’s hit TV series, promises a grand spectacle of illusions. The performers bring a variety of acts, ranging from grand illusions to comedy magic, offering something for every type of magic enthusiast. The show’s fame on television ensures a high-quality production and a diverse range of magic styles. This event is perfect for those who enjoy a large-scale magic performance with a touch of Hollywood glitz​!

This show is a compilation of some of the greatest magicians around, featuring grand-scale illusions, escapology, comedy magic, and sleight of hand. You can expect to see a variety of acts from magicians who have honed their skills to perfection, including classic disappearing acts, cutting-edge illusions, and perhaps even daring escape stunts. The show’s constantly rotating cast keeps it fresh and unpredictable.

Bergen Performing Arts Center, 30 North Van Brunt Street, Englewood, NJ 07631, USA

The Magician at the NoMad Hotel:

Dan White’s “The Magician” show offers a seamless blend of mystery and elegance. Set in the chic NoMad Hotel, the show combines mentalism, illusion, and traditional magic tricks. White’s charismatic performance and the show’s intimate setting make for a mesmerizing evening. It’s an excellent choice for date nights or a sophisticated evening out, offering both wonder and style​​​!

Dan White’s show is a mix of elegance and intrigue. He is known for his sophisticated card tricks, mind-reading acts, and interactive illusions that often involve the entire audience. White’s performance style is polished and smooth, often leaving the audience in awe with his finely crafted magic and the elegant backdrop of the NoMad Hotel enhances the enchanting atmosphere.

NoMad Hotel, 1170 Broadway, New York, NY 10001, USA

Monday Night Magic at Players Theater:

As New York City’s longest-running Off-Broadway magic show, Monday Night Magic offers a weekly dose of astonishment. Each show features a different lineup of world-class magicians, ensuring a fresh and exciting experience every time. The show is a tribute to classic vaudeville magic, offering a variety of acts from illusion to comedy magic. This is a great choice for those who appreciate traditional magic in a theatrical setting​!

This show features a rotating cast of magicians, each bringing their unique style. Expect a variety of acts, from classic rabbit-out-of-the-hat tricks to modern mentalism and interactive magic. Some notable names that have graced the stage include Frank Brents, Michael Chaut, and Peter Samelson. The diversity of performers ensures that no two shows are the same, providing a fresh and exciting experience every week.

Players Theater, 115 MacDougal Street, New York, NY 10012, USA

The Enigmatist at The High Line Hotel:

David Kwong, a magician and crossword puzzle constructor, brings a unique twist to magic shows with The Enigmatist. Set in a historic location, the show combines magic, puzzles, and storytelling, offering an intellectually stimulating experience. This show is perfect for those who enjoy a blend of brain teasers and magic, set in a mysterious, historic New York venue​!

David Kwong’s show combines magic with puzzles and cryptology. Expect an evening filled with mind-bending puzzles, crossword-themed tricks, and interactive code-cracking alongside classic magic. The show’s setting in a historical estate adds to the mysterious and intellectual vibe. Kwong’s unique approach to magic makes this show a treat for puzzle enthusiasts and magic fans alike.

The High Line Hotel, 180 10th Avenue, New York, NY 10011, USA

A Taste of Magic:

This innovative show combines dining with magic, creating a unique entertainment experience. As you enjoy your meal at various New York restaurants, magicians perform close-up magic right at your table. The blend of good food and astonishing magic makes for a memorable evening. This show is an excellent option for a night out with friends or family, offering both a culinary and magical treat​!

This show is unique in that magic is performed table-side in restaurants. Each magician brings their signature tricks, ranging from mentalism to close-up magic, making your dining experience extraordinary. The surprise element of not knowing which magician will perform at your table adds to the excitement. This show combines the pleasures of a fine meal with the thrill of live magic.

The Amazing Max at the Theater at Blessed Sacrament:

Max Darwin’s high-energy performance is suitable for audiences of all ages. The show is interactive, engaging, and features a mix of magic and comedy. Darwin’s ability to connect with both kids and adults makes this show a great choice for family entertainment. The Amazing Max offers a blend of awe-inspiring magic and laugh-out-loud humor, perfect for a fun-filled family outing​​!

Max Darwin is known for his high-energy, interactive magic shows that are perfect for families. Expect a mix of comedy, audience participation, and a variety of magic tricks that appeal to both children and adults. Darwin’s ability to engage and captivate his audience, especially the younger ones, makes this show a memorable experience for families.

The Off-Broadway Magic Show at The Cutting Room

The Off-Broadway Magic Show at The Cutting Room offers a unique blend of sophistication and contemporary magic, making it a standout experience in New York City’s magic scene. Located at The Cutting Room, this show not only features award-winning magicians and mentalists but also provides an immersive experience that starts with close-up magic at your table. Expect to be amazed by a range of illusions, from mind-reading to more traditional magic tricks. The show’s format, which includes a 90-minute stage performance, allows you to witness a variety of styles and techniques from some of the best magicians in the world. The cozy atmosphere of The Cutting Room, combined with the option of dinner and drinks, creates a perfect setting for an evening filled with wonder and entertainment. This show is particularly appealing for those looking to experience magic up close in a sophisticated yet relaxed environment.

Address: The Cutting Room, 44 E 32nd St, New York, NY 10016

Speakeasy Magick at The McKittrick Hotel

Speakeasy Magick at The McKittrick Hotel transports you to a world of enchantment and surprise. Hosted in the mystical McKittrick Hotel, this show stands out for its intimate and interactive nature. Spearheaded by the charismatic magician Todd Robbins, the evening is filled with a series of magicians performing breathtaking illusions right at your table. The show’s ambiance, reminiscent of a bygone era, adds to the allure, making it an ideal setting for those seeking a night of sophisticated entertainment. The McKittrick Hotel’s unique setting, combined with top-notch magicians, ensures an evening of high-quality performances. Guests can enjoy cocktails and a vibrant atmosphere, making this an excellent choice for a night out in Chelsea. The show’s format, which encourages magicians to engage directly with the audience, ensures a personal and unforgettable magical experience.

Address: The McKittrick Hotel, 542 W 27th St, New York, NY 10001.

Asi Wind’s Inner Circle at The Judson Theatre

Asi Wind’s Inner Circle, hosted at The Judson Theatre, is a testament to the power of close-up magic and storytelling. Wind, known for his exceptional skill in card magic, offers a show that is both intimate and mind-blowing. His performances are a blend of drama, storytelling, and magic, ensuring an immersive experience for the audience. Praised by none other than David Blaine, Wind’s show is a masterclass in the art of magic. The Judson Theatre provides a cozy and personal atmosphere, ideal for Wind’s style of performance. Expect to be a part of a show where card tricks are not just tricks, but stories that captivate and astonish. This show is perfect for those who appreciate the nuances of magic and enjoy being part of a close-knit audience.

Address: 243 Thompson St, New York, NY 10012 (The Judson Theatre)

Divine Spirits: A Night of Magic & Cocktails at The Paris Cafe

Divine Spirits: A Night of Magic & Cocktails, located at The Paris Cafe, combines the world of magic and mixology for a truly unique experience. The show features mentalists and magicians Mark Clearview and Melissa Derfler, who present a series of hilarious and impossible performances. This includes mind reading and escapology, all complemented by the art of cocktail making. The Paris Cafe, one of New York’s oldest brasseries, provides a historic and elegant backdrop for an evening of entertainment. The combination of magic and specially curated cocktails creates an atmosphere of sophistication and amusement. This show is ideal for those looking for a blend of humor, mystery, and a touch of class in their magical experience.

Address: 119 South St, New York, NY 10038

Illusionist Matt Roberts Mixes Comedy & Magic

Illusionist Matt Roberts’ show is a delightful mix of comedy and magic, perfect for audiences seeking entertainment that combines laughter with awe. Roberts, an award-winning magician, is known for his charismatic stage presence and a repertoire that includes sleight of hand, levitation, and mind-reading tricks. His performances are dynamic, engaging, and often include unexpected twists on classic Houdini specials. The show’s format allows Roberts to showcase his versatility, blending different styles of magic with humor. It’s an ideal event for a wide range of audiences, from families to magic enthusiasts, looking for a show that is both amusing and astonishing. While the specific location is not provided in the source, further details can be found on their website.

The Parlour of Deceptions by Daniel Roy at the Salmagundi Club

The Parlour of Deceptions, performed by Daniel Roy at the SalmagundiClub, is an exclusive magic show that is a must-see for those who love intimate and sophisticated magic. Limited to only 30 guests per show, Roy’s performances are a close-up spectacle of sleight-of-hand and misdirection. His shows are characterized by humor and a high level of audience interaction, making each performance a personal and engaging experience. Roy’s magic is not just about tricks; it’s about creating an atmosphere of wonder and disbelief. The Salmagundi Club, with its rich history and elegant setting, provides the perfect backdrop for Roy’s mesmerizing performances. This show is highly recommended for those seeking an intimate and unforgettable magical evening.

Address: Salmagundi Club, 47 5th Ave, New York, NY 10003

New York City, a metropolis that never sleeps, is a magical place in more ways than one. It has a rich history of magic shows that dates back to the early 20th century when magicians like Harry Houdini captivated audiences with their daring escapes and sleight of hand. Over the years, the city has continued to be a hub for magicians and illusionists, from legendary performers to up-and-coming artists, each adding their unique flavor to the NYC magic scene.

The magic shows in New York City offer a diverse range of experiences. From intimate close-up magic at quaint venues to grand stage illusions at prestigious theaters, there is something for everyone. These performances are not just about tricks and illusions; they are about storytelling, wonder, and often, a dash of comedy. They transcend the boundaries of age, language, and culture, making them a universal form of entertainment. Whether it’s the awe-inspiring feats at The Off-Broadway Magic Show, the sophisticated parlor magic of Chamber Magic, or the innovative and interactive experiences at The Magician at the NoMad Hotel, each show promises an evening full of surprises and enchantment.

Adding to the city’s magic allure is Abracadabra NYC, a renowned destination for both new and professional magicians. It’s more than just a store; it’s a part of the city’s magic community. Here, enthusiasts and professionals alike can find everything they need, from basic magic supplies to intricate props and costumes. Abracadabra NYC is not just a store; it’s a place where magic is kept alive, where stories are shared, and where the next generation of magicians finds inspiration.

In summary, the magic shows of New York City offer a blend of history, artistry, and excitement. They are a testament to the city’s vibrant entertainment scene and its enduring love affair with the art of magic. Whether you are a local or a visitor, a night at one of these shows is an opportunity to step into a world of wonder and experience the timeless joy of being utterly mystified.